Choices in Dentistry vs Post Family Dental In The Loop: which fits All-on-4/6 implants?
Both practices score near the top of our methodology for Chicago dental implant providers, but they serve different starting points for someone weighing All-on-4/All-on-6 treatment. Choices in Dentistry brings decades of biological and functional dentistry experience that matters for complex full-arch cases, while Post Family Dental leans on a smaller, high-touch practice built around comfort and communication during a long treatment process.
Verdict
The right pick depends on what you need most from an All-on-4/All-on-6 provider. If the priority is deep clinical experience with functional and biological methods that can matter for a full-arch implant plan, Choices in Dentistry's decades-long track record and specialist team make it the stronger match. If the priority is a calm, closely managed experience with quick access when something goes wrong, Post Family Dental's smaller-practice model and emergency responsiveness fit better. Both carry near-identical composite scores, so this comes down to what kind of care experience you want during a demanding treatment process, not which one is objectively better.
Which should you pick?
Pick Choices in Dentistry if
- You want a practice with decades of experience and a biological/functional approach (ozone, SMART mercury removal, TMJ work) that can support a complex implant case
- You value having named specialists (Dr. Gilleran, Dr. Sutherland, myofunctional therapist Toni) involved in different aspects of care
- You prefer a practice with a long track record of patients staying 15+ years
Pick Post Family Dental In The Loop if
- You're anxious about implant surgery and want a practice known for calming nervous patients
- You want same-day emergency access and close, personal follow-up from one dentist (Dr. Post)
- You prefer a smaller, modern office in the Loop with a no-rush pace
The differences that matter
- Depth of complex-case experience. Choices in Dentistry has 30+ years treating patients with long tenures (15-37 years) and a track record of catching problems other dentists miss, which matters for planning a full-arch implant case; Post Family Dental's praise centers more on day-to-day comfort and emergency responsiveness.
- Biological and functional approach vs streamlined comfort model. Choices in Dentistry integrates ozone therapy, SMART mercury-safe removal, TMJ treatment and myofunctional therapy (Toni) that can support jaw function and healing around implants, whereas Post Family Dental doesn't mention these adjunct therapies in its profile.
- Practice size and pacing. Post Family Dental is a small, modern Loop office with a no-rush approach and same-day emergency slots, useful if you want quick access and personal follow-up from Dr. Post during the implant process; Choices in Dentistry's team-based model spreads expertise across named specialists like Dr. Gilleran, Dr. Sutherland and hygienists Erica and Erika.
- Anxiety management. Post Family Dental specifically calls out helping nervous patients feel at ease, which can matter for a multi-visit implant surgery; Choices in Dentistry's calm stems more from long-term trust built over years rather than an explicit anxiety-focused approach.
Side by side
- Google rating
- Choices in Dentistry: 5 (400 reviews)
- Post Family Dental In The Loop: 5 (340 reviews)
- Services
- Choices in Dentistry: full mouth implants, all on 4 all on 6, single tooth implants
- Post Family Dental In The Loop: full mouth implants, all on 4 all on 6, single tooth implants, implant dentistry specialist
- Best for complex full-arch planning
- Choices in Dentistry: Strong fit given functional/biological dentistry background and long-tenured patient base
- Post Family Dental In The Loop: Adequate, but profile emphasizes general and emergency care over full-arch complexity
- Best for a nervous or first-time implant patient
- Choices in Dentistry: Good, but reviews focus more on trust built over years than in-the-moment anxiety care
- Post Family Dental In The Loop: Strong fit, explicitly praised for calming nervous patients and no-rush pacing
- Access and follow-up during treatment
- Choices in Dentistry: Efficient office with a full team of specialists sharing the workload
- Post Family Dental In The Loop: Same-day emergency appointments and personal follow-up directly from Dr. Post
- Verification
- Choices in Dentistry: Google-verified
- Post Family Dental In The Loop: Google-verified
- Composite score
- Choices in Dentistry: 95
- Post Family Dental In The Loop: 94
Within 3 points of each other, so treat them as effectively tied on overall quality. The choice below is about fit, not the score.
What reviewers say
Choices in Dentistry
Patients consistently report feeling trusted and cared for. Most have been with the practice for 15-37 years, valuing the dentists' refusal to recommend unnecessary work and their attention to detecting problems others miss. Dr. Gilleran and Dr. Nellie Sutherland are named frequently. Myofunctional therapy with Toni has impressed new patients with its comprehensive approach to breathing and posture.
The practice blends traditional dentistry with biological methods: ozone therapy, mercury-safe amalgam removal (SMART technique), and functional approaches like TMJ treatment. Hygienists, especially Erica and Erika, are praised for both thoroughness and gentleness. The office runs efficiently, and staff from front desk through doctors are described as knowledgeable and invested in patient success.
Post Family Dental In The Loop
Patients describe Post Family Dental as exceptionally caring and thorough. Staff accommodate emergencies, explain procedures clearly, and make nervous patients feel at ease. Dr. Post answers questions patiently and follows up after treatment.
A small, modern practice in the Loop with standout service. Hygienist Jenni and Dr. Brian Post earn specific praise. Reviewers consistently note the professional yet personal atmosphere, no-rush approach, and views of Chicago from the office. Few dentists get recognition for helping non-patients on weekends.
Still not sure which is right for you?
Describe what you need and get consultation offers from dental implants provider in Chicago, IL
When you submit an enquiry through our forms, we may share it with partner providers who perform the work, and we may receive a referral fee for these matches. Our rankings and scores are determined by our published methodology alone and are never influenced by referral fees.
FAQ
- Which practice has more experience with complex implant cases?
- Choices in Dentistry's profile points to more depth here, with 30+ years in practice and biological/functional methods like TMJ treatment and myofunctional therapy that support full-arch planning.
- Which is better for someone nervous about implant surgery?
- Post Family Dental is specifically praised for helping nervous patients feel at ease and for a no-rush approach, which may suit anxious patients better.
- Does either practice offer emergency support during treatment?
- Post Family Dental explicitly offers same-day emergency appointments and personal follow-up from Dr. Post; this isn't mentioned in Choices in Dentistry's profile.
- Are both practices similarly rated?
- Yes, both carry composite scores above 94 with 5-star Google ratings from 400 and 340 reviews respectively, so the decision comes down to fit rather than overall quality.