Perio Implant Chicago vs New Teeth Chicago Dental: which for bone grafting and sinus lift?
Verdict
For bone grafting and sinus lift specifically, the deciding factor is who treats grafting as their main specialty versus a step toward a bigger implant case, and how reachable the office is once the graft needs monitoring. Perio Implant Chicago fits patients who want periodontists focused on the graft itself and reliable follow-up calls during healing. New Teeth Chicago Dental fits patients already set on a full-mouth or All-on-4 plan who prioritize Dr. Atcha's implant credentials and can tolerate some friction reaching the office afterward.
Which should you pick?
Pick Perio Implant Chicago if
- You want a periodontist-led team whose core practice is bone grafting, gum recession, and implant site prep
- You value being called after the procedure to check on healing rather than having to chase the office
- You might need emergency extraction access on short notice
Pick New Teeth Chicago Dental if
- Your case involves full-mouth reconstruction or All-on-4 implants where sinus lift is one part of a bigger plan
- You want a surgeon with DICOI and DIDIA diplomat credentials specifically
- You're comfortable handling scheduling proactively if phone follow-up is slow
Side by side
- Google rating
- Perio Implant Chicago: 4.9 (348 reviews)
- New Teeth Chicago Dental: 5 (480 reviews)
- Services
- Perio Implant Chicago: implant supported dentures, implant dentistry specialist, bone grafting sinus lift, full mouth implants
- New Teeth Chicago Dental: implant supported dentures, implant dentistry specialist, bone grafting sinus lift, full mouth implants
- Best for
- Perio Implant Chicago: Patients wanting a periodontal specialist focused on grafting and gum health as a distinct discipline
- New Teeth Chicago Dental: Patients already committed to a full-mouth or All-on-4 implant plan where grafting is one step in a larger case
- Communication during healing
- Perio Implant Chicago: Proactive follow-up calls reported by reviewers
- New Teeth Chicago Dental: Mixed reports, including trouble reaching the office by phone
- Verification
- Perio Implant Chicago: Google-verified
- New Teeth Chicago Dental: Google-verified
- Composite score
- Perio Implant Chicago: 93
- New Teeth Chicago Dental: 91
Within 3 points of each other, so treat them as effectively tied on overall quality. The choice below is about fit, not the score.
What reviewers say
Perio Implant Chicago
Reviewers consistently describe a team that listens carefully and explains procedures step by step, leaving patients confident in their treatment plans. Dr. Sheppard and Dr. Sabzehei perform extractions, grafting, and periodontal work with a gentle touch, follow up by phone after procedures, and maintain a welcoming environment where staff remember returning patients by name.
Expertise spans bone grafting, gum recession treatment, laser gum contouring, and implant planning across the full-mouth and single-tooth spectrum. The office handles emergency extractions within an hour and sits in a convenient Goose Island location with inside parking.
New Teeth Chicago Dental
Most reviewers rave about Dr. Atcha's implant expertise and the team's surgical precision, with patients reporting life-changing smile transformations and comfortable recoveries. However, some struggle to reach the office by phone or secure follow-up appointments, and one early review cited delayed hygienist callback.
The practice offers full-mouth reconstruction and All-on-4 implants with same-day temporary teeth options. Dr. Atcha combines advanced credentials (DICOI and DIDIA diplomat status) with a listening approach to complex cases, though communication delays after surgery have tested patient confidence in ongoing support.
Still not sure which is right for you?
Describe what you need and get consultation offers from dental implants provider in Chicago, IL
When you submit an enquiry through our forms, we may share it with partner providers who perform the work, and we may receive a referral fee for these matches. Our rankings and scores are determined by our published methodology alone and are never influenced by referral fees.
FAQ
- Which practice has more experience specifically with bone grafting and sinus lifts?
- Perio Implant Chicago's periodontists focus on grafting, gum recession, and implant site preparation as core work, while New Teeth Chicago Dental treats grafting as part of larger full-mouth implant cases led by Dr. Atcha.
- Which one is easier to reach after a grafting procedure?
- Perio Implant Chicago reviewers report follow-up phone calls to check on healing. New Teeth Chicago Dental has some complaints about unreturned messages and scheduling difficulty.
- Does either offer emergency care if complications arise after grafting?
- Perio Implant Chicago offers same-day or next-day emergency extraction scheduling. No equivalent emergency access is mentioned for New Teeth Chicago Dental.
- Which has the higher overall rating or more reviews?
- New Teeth Chicago Dental has 480 reviews at a 5.0 rating versus Perio Implant Chicago's 348 reviews at 4.9, though Perio Implant Chicago scores higher on sentiment (0.81 vs 0.67).